top of page
  • Transformative Research's Facebook Account
  • Transformative Research's Instagram Account
  • Transformative Research's YouTube
  • Transformative Research's Twitter Account
  • Threads
Colorful Books

New Report

Conversations that
Shift the Ground

Exploring Outcomes Associated with the Culturally Responsive English Language Arts and Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, and Math Curriculum Evaluation Tools

research summary

overview

The CRE ELA & STEAM Scorecards were developed as collaborative and participatory evaluation tools to help parents, communities, teachers, and schools to understand opportunities for culturally responsive in their curriculum. Since their release, the use of the Scorecards spread across the United States.

 

Scorecard users submitted numerous emails, training requests, presentation inquiries, and requests for additional information as they used the Scorecards in their school communities. Alongside this widespread interest, compelling narratives emerged about the transformative impact of the Scorecards within school communities.

These informal feedback loops prompted EJ-ROC and Transformative Research to design a formal research study to systematically explore and document outcomes associated with using the Scorecards.

research question

​What outcomes are associated with using the CRE ELA Scorecard or CRSE STEM Scorecard?​​

methods

Participants

44 participants from Mississippi, Alabama, North Carolina, New York, Michigan, Illinois, Colorado, and California participated

Interviews &

Focus Groups

We asked participants about their motivation for using the Scorecard(s), how they used the Scorecard(s), immediate, short-term, and long-term outcomes using the Scorecard(s).

Questionnaire

We asked participants 50 questions about how they used the Scorecards, how Scorecard results informed their practice and curriculum, and short-term outcomes associated with using the Scorecards.

Artifacts & Documents

Some participants shared examples of their work that resulted from using the Scorecards.

KEY FINDINGS

Finding #1

The Scorecards prompted powerful conversations by (a) fostering a shared understanding and perspective of curricula, (b) building awareness and language to address inequities in curriculum, and (c) collaborative decision-making power about curricula.

Finding #2

Participants used Scorecard results to advance the availability and use of culturally responsive curriculum. This was achieved by (a) replacing harmful and destructive books, texts, and materials; (b) strengthening CRE knowledge; (c) modifying curriculum and lesson plans; and (d) advocating for culturally responsive curricula.

Finding #3

Using the Scorecard changed the way school communities operate.

report in action:
videos, blogs, & data

Report Overview

Video

Watch this video for an overview of the report, key findings, and why they matter.

Click here

Curriculum in Context

Video

Watch to understand how our findings connect with other research on curriculum studies.

Click here

Data Snapshot

Data Excerpts

Dig into the data! Explore data excerpts and figures first hand. 

Click here

Blog Title

Blog

Do these findings challenge what other research says about curriculum?

Click here

Coming Soon!

Webinar

Join us for a conversation about the study and culturally responsive curriculum in a 2025 context!

Click here

Blog Title

Blog

Check out our blog with partner NYU Metro Center announcing the report. 

Click here
  • What are Curriculum Studies?
    What are curriculum Studies? Curriculum Studies is the study of what and how students learn in schools. It looks at the subjects, lessons, and activities that teachers use to help students gain knowledge and skills. People who study curriculum think about questions like: What should students learn? (Math, science, history, social skills, etc.) How should they learn it? (Through books, projects, hands-on activities, discussions, etc.) Who decides what is taught? (Teachers, school leaders, government, communities, etc.) Curriculum Studies also looks at how learning connects to students' lives, cultures, and communities. It asks whether the lessons and materials are fair, helpful, and interesting for all students. People who work in this field help improve education by making sure school learning is meaningful and prepares students for the future.
  • What is curriculum?
    Curriculum is what students learn in school and how they learn it. It includes the subjects they study, like math, science, and history, as well as the books, lessons, and activities teachers use to help them understand these topics. Curriculum also includes the skills students practice, such as problem-solving, teamwork, and critical thinking. Schools decide what to teach based on state or national guidelines, but teachers may adjust lessons to fit their students' needs.
  • What is Culturally Responsive Education & Curriculum?
    Culturally responsive sustaining education is defined as “a cultural view of learning and human development in which multiple expressions of diversity (e.g., race, sexual orientation, gender, social class, etc.) are recognized and regarded as assets for teaching and learning” (NYSED, 2019). The foundations of CRSE are largely rooted in Gloria Ladson-Billings’s, Geneva Gay’s, and D’Jango Paris’s scholarship around culturally relevant pedagogy, culturally responsive teaching, and culturally sustaining pedagogy (Ladson-Billings, 1994, 1995; Gay, 2000; Paris, 2012). Research studies documented several positive outcomes of culturally responsive education, including increased standardized test scores, higher attendance rates, higher graduation rates, greater student engagement, and improved teacher-student relationships (Aronson & Laughter, 2016).
  • Where Can I Find the Scorecards?
    The Culturally Responsive ELA Curriculum Scorecard See Scorecard: View Curriculum Report Using Scorecard: Culturally Responsive-Sustaining STEAM Curriculum Scorecard See Scorecard: View Curriculum Report Using Scorecard:
  • How Can I use the Scorecards?
    Download the Scorecards, the toolkit to conduct your own scoring party (Curriculum evaluation) or contact Dr. Leah to help you plan your own Scoring Party. Visit the contact page and select Curriculum Evaluation.
  • Why are you exploring culture in curriculum? Isn't curriculum neutral?
    Curriculum is not neutral or culture-free. Every curriculum is shaped by the people who design it, the perspectives they bring, and the choices they make about what is important to learn. For example, history textbooks often highlight certain events and figures while leaving out others. Literature classes focus on specific authors, usually from dominant cultures. Even subjects like math and science, which may seem neutral, reflect cultural values in the way they are taught—such as whether students learn through memorization, hands-on activities, or group work. By exploring culture in curriculum, we can make learning more inclusive and meaningful for all students. When different backgrounds, histories, and ways of thinking are represented, students get a fuller, more accurate understanding of the world and their place in it.
  • What do you mean by "participatory" evaluation?
    Participatory approaches to evaluation is a way of studying and improving programs by involving the people who are most affected by them. Instead of just having outside experts do the research, participatory evaluation includes teachers, students, community members, or anyone directly connected to the program. This approach allows people to share their ideas, experiences, and opinions to help understand what is working well and what needs to change. It encourages teamwork, respects different viewpoints, and helps create solutions that fit the needs of the community. By working together, everyone has a role in shaping better outcomes.
bottom of page